| A1 | Main Title (The Second Star to the Right)/All This Happened Before |
| A2 | On the Rooftop/What's a Kiss/Perturbed Pixie |
| A3 | You Can Fly! You Can Fly! You Can Fly! |
| A4 | A Pirate's Life |
| A5 | Blast That Peter Pan/A Pirate's Life (Reprise) |
| A6 | The Legend of the Croc/Double the Powder and Shorten the Fuse/Follow Tinker Bell |
| A7 | Following the Leader |
| B1 | Hide and Sneak/No Let 'em Go |
| B2 | Plotting a Pixie's Plight |
| B3 | What Made the Red Man Red/Tinknapped |
| B4 | Rumor Has It/Hangman's Tree |
| B5 | Your Mother and Mine |
| B6 | Captain Hook Never Breaks A Promise/The Elegant Captain Hook/A Little Surprise/Oh Tink/The Pen or the Plank |
| B7 | No Splash/Take That/I'm a Codfish!/Crocbait/The Hero of Neverland |
| B8 | Home Again/Mermaids, Pirates, and Indians/Finale (You Can Fly! You Can Fly! You Can Fly!) |
